In a strange gamble rookie Essendon coach Matthew Knights made a late decision to drop his only recognised ruckman for the Elimination Final against Adelaide at AAMI Stadium last night. With his best quality tall men either injured or suspended, Knights made the call to go with a smaller running side, opening the way for first year Irish player Michael Quinn to be brought up from the emergency list.
Although having the willingness to make such a dramatic decision has to be respected, the reality is it was a disastrous outcome for the Bombers. Adelaide dominated the ruck like rarely seen in the AFL, with Ivan Maric and James Sellar running amok, their side registering 64 hit outs to 18. It wasn't just the number, but the decisiveness of the taps, meaning the Crows could set up their midfield knowing they had first use of the ball. Although a big win was always likely, there's no doubt the ruck situation contributed to the 96 point margin, Essendon's biggest ever loss in a final in their 102 year VFL/AFL history.
For his part Quinn had a very mixed game. It must be emphasised he was not selected as a replacement ruckman, instead playing through the midfield and sneaking forward. He marked early on uncontested but his set shot from about 25 metres out on a 45 degree angle was extremely poor with bad timing off the boot and only just registered a point. He atoned for that later in the quarter with another uncontested mark and goal from in front. One can only imagine the huge pressure on that second shot at goal, playing in his first final in his first year of Australian football with 50,000 spectators making a lot of noise.