World Footy News

Proving that the so-called Irish experiment is just that, an experiment, young Carlton recruit Michael Shields has joined the growing list of Irishmen to return to his homeland without making a success of an AFL career. The transition to a full contact, professional sporting environment can be too much for many prospective players. Some Australian draftees find the demands on their minds and bodies too great, so it's no surprise the toll is even greater for recruits drawn from a different sport on the other side of the world.

Although the announcement of the loss of the rookie-listed player is not likely to slow the search for international talent, it does come at a time when Sydney's Tadhg Kennelly continues to warn that AFL clubs are not equipped to handle the needs of such recruits.

Kennelly himself, injury permitting, becomes the third Gaelic recruit to play 150 VFL/AFL games, following Jim Stynes and Sean Wight (Scottish born/Irish raised). It's a great achievement, particularly as he has struggled through injuries this season, in one match dislocating his shoulder and knee in separate incidents, and last week popping his shoulder twice. But like Stynes before him, Kennelly battles on without missing matches.

Meanwhile the somewhat far-fetched but seriously considered idea of Western Sydney having a Sydney Celtic theme has been firmly dismissed by the AFL. The new side will look to embrace the new migrant communities of the area, which are by no means heavily Irish.

Shields was Carlton’s fourth round selection in the 2008 NAB Rookie Draft, but will return home immediately and resume his Gaelic football career.

“I miss home and I’ve been fighting that for a while and while I could have battled it out for another 2 or 3 months I had made my decision.”

“While realizing the game wasn’t for me, I have a greater appreciation for the game of AFL.”

“I wish to take the opportunity to thank the Carlton Football Club for what they have done for me. While I’m disappointed that everything didn’t work out perfectly, it was still a great experience and one that I will never forget.”

“I extend my best wishes to the playing group on a bright and successful future.”